Is Simply Nourish Cat Food Good Quality?

Yes, Simply Nourish is one of premium-quality pet food producers. It uses deboned meat, poultry and fish, as well as other wholesome ingredients (fruits, vegetables) in recipes. No animal by-products are used. The vast majority of recipes are grain-free, which is considered to be a healthier option, especially for allergic cats. However, a few recipes are made with oatmeal and brown rice to add the calories and nutritional value. Peas and potatoes are often used as the primary source of fiber. 

While the dry food is produced on facilities located in Utah, Simply Nourish wet cat food is manufactured in Thailand. The manufacturer claims that the raw material is exported from all over the world. Thus, it’s not clear what the origin of this or that component is – thus is a significant drawback. According to the company’s representative, the foods produced in the US are made of US-sourced meats, while Thailand facilities process That-sourced components. 

Also, Simply Nourish uses anonymous meats in a few recipes (fish, ocean fish, animal digest, animal flavor). The origin of those meats is unknown – it can be any animal. 

About Simply Nourish Company/Brand

Simply Nourish brand appeared on the shelves of PetSmart in May 2011 – this is one of store brands. The company focuses on the production of pet nutrition of carefully-sourced ingredients, real fruits and vegetables, and deboned meat. The brand offers both dog and cat foods, and strives to provide optimal food variants for cats of all ages and species. 

What are the ingredients in Simply Nourish Cat Food?

As we have already mentioned, Simply Nourish uses high-quality wholesome ingredients: deboned meat and fish, fruits, vegetables, seeds, and in rare cases – grains. The vast majority of recipes are grain-free because it’s more appropriate for carnivorous pets. Yet, some recipes contain oatmeal and rice, which is explicitly written on the package.

To promote better digestion, Simply Nourish puts a lot of vegetable-based ingredients, for example:

  • Peas;
  • Potato;
  • Tomato.

Also, the manufacturer often uses dried eggs, canola oil, vegetable oil and rosemary extract to improve the formula and flavor. Some controversial components include guar gum, flaxseed meal, potato starch, and sunflower oil.

Apart from that, the nutritional value of Simply Nourish cat food ingredients is raised by a rich amount of vitamins and minerals. Those include:

  • Vitamins E, A, D3, B12, C
  • L-Carnitine;
  • Taurine;
  • Minerals (Zinc Sulfate, Ferrous Sulfate, Calcium Iodate, Copper Sulfate, Manganese Sulfate, Calcium Carbonate, Sodium Selenite, Calcium Iodate).

Thus, Simply Nourish serves as a great option for primary nutrition for a cat. Wet and dry foods can complement one another.

There is only one considerable disadvantage: most recipes contain salt, and there are no specific types of food for sterile cats. If your cat is prone to kidney inflammation, Simply Nourish might not be the best option. 

P.S.: All packages of Simply Nourish cat foods (both dry and wet) come with a bonus Especiales Cosas Mixing Spatula.

Has it been recalled?

So far, there has been no negative Simply Nourish cat food recall. The brand has a good reputation: no issues with the food quality, contamination, or poor packaging have been reported. 

Judging by customer reviews, the vast majority of pet parents are content with the quality of Simply Nourish cat food: their pets like its flavor and feel good after switching to a new diet. No serious allergies or stomach disorders have been reported. However, a few users complained that the company changed the recipes’ formulas which affected cats’ appetite. Such feedback are pretty rare, though.

What kinds of food does it offer?

The manufacturer produces both wet and dry foods that are primarily divided into four series:

  1. Whole Health is a vitamin & mineral-rich series that’s made to address the needs of cats at all life stages.
  2. Limited Ingredient lineup is created for cats with food sensitivities. Such recipes contain about 5 ingredients with one major protein source and one type of carbohydrate.
  3. Grain-Free foods are produced without grains. However, those usually include pea and potato protein.
  4. Simply Nourish Source series contains a high amount of protein (up to 40%) and a reduced level of carbohydrates. This is a good option for indoor cats with a low level of activity and low calorie demand. 

We should note that Simply Nourish generally divides foods into ‘adult’ and ‘kitten’ series. There are no special lineups for senior, pregnant or sterile cats. Thus, the owner is responsible for developing a well-balanced diet for his cats. We recommend visiting a veterinarian: a specialist will help you figure out the optimal daily dosage of protein, vitamins, and calories. Ideally, you should combine both dry and wet cat food types. 

FAQ

Is Simply Nourish Cat Food Grain-Free?

The vast majority of Simply Nourish foods do not contain grains: instead, the manufacturer uses vegetables, fruits, and seeds to promote healthy digestion. Yet, a few recipes contain grains. For example, Simply Nourish lineup includes Chicken/Oatmeal and Turkey/Oatmeal recipes for adult cats, Chicken/Brown rice recipe for kittens, as well as one recipe with rice flour. As a rule, grains are used in kibble production as a binding agent – they are not appropriate for cats and cause allergy in some pets. However, if your cat tolerates grains well and needs very substantial meals (it concerns kittens and pregnant cats primarily), this option is agreeable.

Who makes Simply Nourish cat food?

According to the manufacturer, Simply Nourish dry food is produced on the facilities in Utah. Wet food is produced in Thailand. Simply Nourish is the brand belonging to PetSmart Inc. – the biggest retailer of pet services and solutions for daily pet care, including nutrition. The company runs 1,100+ stores in the USA and Canada and is actively participating in pet charity. 

Thus, Simply Nourish cat food recipes were formulated by PetSmart specialists to address the needs of cats and maintain their health. The company strives to offer the products of exceptional quality by using wholesome ingredients, vitamins, and minerals.

How much to feed my cat with Simply Nourish cat food?

Each cat needs a different amount of calories and proteins, however, Simply Nourish offers the following directions:

DRY FOOD (one 8 oz cup of dry cat food contains ~300 kcal).

Kittens:

Kitten’s Weight8-15 weeks16-25 weeks26-35 weeks
2-4 lbs1/2 – 1 1/4 cups1/2 – 2/3 cups
5-8 lbs
3/4 – 1 1/4 cups1/2 – 1 cups
9-12 lbs

1 – 1 1/2 cups

Adult Cats:

WeightDry cups per dayWater to add
1-5 lbs1/8 – 1/4 cup1/8 – 1/4 cup
6-10 lbs1/4 – 1/2 cup1/4 – 1/2 cup
11-16 lbs1/2 – 3/4 cup1/2 – 3/4 cup
17-21 lbs3/4 – 1 cup3/4 – 1 cup

Thus, when you feed your cat dry food, the volume of water consumed should equal the volume of kibbles eaten. It will help you avoid problems with digestion and dehydration. 

WET FOOD


1-5 lbs5-10 lbs10-15 lbs15-20 lbs
Kitten200 kcal300 kcal600 kcal800 kcal
Lean adult cat170 kcal280 kcal360 kcal440 kcal
Overweight cat180 kcal240 kcal280 kcal310 kcal
Pregnant/Nursing cat336 kcal603 kcal851 kcal1091 kcal

When figuring out the appropriate daily portions for your cat, please follow the directions provided on the label. Also, you may visit a veterinarian to define how much dry and wet food your kitten/cat should eat. Make sure your pet gets enough water – it is extremely important for health and overall well-being.

What is the quality of Simply Nourish high-protein grain-free diet cat food?

Overall, the food from Simply Nourish is made of high-quality ingredients and has a high nutritional value. Since it does not contain grains, it will not cause digestion problems or allergies. The primary ingredients are safe.

However, many recipes from Simply Nourish contain such ingredients as flaxseed oil, vegetable oil, sunflower oil, canola oil, and dried egg products. Before you start changing your cat’s diet, make sure that your pet is not allergic to the above-mentioned components. Also, potato starch and tomato pomace are not quite safe for cats: they might cause inflammation and allergy. Try to avoid recipes with those ingredients. 

If your cat suffers from sensitivities, we recommend trying Limited Ingredient series: the recipes have up to 5 components and don’t cause digestion disorders in cats. There is a wide variety of flavors, so you will definitely find something that appeals to your cat. 

Simply Nourish customers admit there is one disadvantage: the dry food from Simply Nourish contains a lot of ash: in some packages, it may be up to 3% (which is agreeable), in others, it reaches 8% meaning a lot of dust is left in cat’s bowl. It might be the result of improper transportation conditions. Yet, this is not appropriate for a premium cat food brand.

How much carbs are in Simply Nourish Source cat food

It should be noted that most recipes from Simply Nourish contain an optimal amount of protein and carbohydrates. The Source series was formulated to help cats maintain an optimal weight and receive just the right amount of calories. Most dry foods contain about 39-40% of protein, 10% of fat, and 23-26% of carbohydrates. Thus, the majority of calories come from protein, and only 22% of calories are obtained from carbohydrates. 

The dry food from Simply Nourish contains about 350-375 kcal per one 8 oz cup, which is slightly higher than normal. Yet, the food is rich in vitamins and lasts longer since cats need smaller portions. 

Wet foods from Simply Nourish contain protein and about 75% of moisture: read the nutrition facts to find out how many carbs the foods contain. 

Where to buy Simply Nourish cat food?

You can purchase Simply Nourish cat food directly at the retailer’s store: there are hundreds of PetSmart stores around the USA. As a rule, the stores provide the whole lineup of foods and allow customers to order some series of foods. However, in this case, you might have to wait for several days or weeks for your order to be delivered.

If you need some particular type of Simply Nourish food, it is easier to make a purchase online. Instead of visiting local pet stores, open Amazon website and find the Simply Nourish cat food types you need. Apart from the official brand store, there are several sellers offering the whole gamut of foods. 

Why this option is more agreeable?

  • First, the delivery time is way shorter (most orders are shipped within a couple of days);
  • Secondly, bulk purchases made on Amazon will save you a pretty penny;
  • Thirdly, Amazon sellers have special offers and discounts. 

To make an order, click the links in our reviews and proceed to the Amazon pages offering the food. Check out the list of sellers and available offers. 

I am Claudine, a College of Veterinary Medicine alumni and cat health & lifestyle specialist. In this blog, I share my personal experience and recommendations on improving cat’s diet, behavior, and both physical and psychological state.

20 Comments

  • Kyle Roberts

    Thanks for the review, it’s been quite interesting to read about different products of my cat’s favorite brand! Actually, my fluffy loves Simply Nourish cat food with Treat, Tuna and Salmon most of all, though she likes other flavors too; but this one is her fav. Is it a full list of products Simply Nourish produces? Are there some more to review?

  • Baby Cat

    Gosh, I knew only about SIMPLY NOURISH Adult Dry Cat Food, didn’t know that they have so many products and flavors. Thanks for the part where you describe the quality of the food, it’s very useful, I guess the percentage is everything when it concerns a special diet. I once bought a diet no-grain food; however, it turned out there were some grains in it. Do they place the full list of the vegetables and fruits on the etiquette?

  • Getitright111

    Cool review, thanks for the detailed description of all the products, it’s been really helpful as right now I am choosing between SIMPLY NOURISH Wet Cat Food Adult Turkey and Pumpkin and Venison Recipe. So it’s great that you write about all these pros and cons. Right now I think I have a winner of the battle, however, I will write about the results a little bit later. I would also love to read a detailed guide about Simply Nourish Freeze Dried Cat Treats. I heard a lot of cool reviews about this product as well.

  • Jane Cat5

    Now I think I have one more favorite product, so thanks for the interesting article; I will definitely show it to my friend. She is a vet at the animal shelter next to my house and right now she is searching for some new cool brands for her kitties. Are there any more kitten products except for chicken recipe?

  • MeowOfTheWorld

    Totally agree with all that is written in the article, I must confess, I bought almost every product on the list. I started with kitten chicken recipe as soon as my baby cat entered the house. As Mr Catman grew older, I bought other products as well, however, Simply Nourish Source Wet Cat Food Adult Venison turned out to be my cat’s favorite food. As soon as he smells the flavor, he starts meowing like crazy, so right now I am intrigued which flavor they’ll produce next.

  • Fiona Texas

    The most exciting thing in the article is that you not only describe the list of the products, it’s pros and cons, but also give information about all possible recalls. I’ve read a lot of articles here and I am very delighted that all the authors mention such an important fact. And, of course, it’s cool that Simply Nourish hasn’t been recalled; PetSmart Inc. is a great retailer so I always buy products of this brand for my cat. I also never knew that the food contains so many calories per cup; I guess I’ll give smaller portions to my fluffy. Do all the wet food products contain 75% of moisture or only those mentioned in the article?

  • MaryJane555

    I can’t even imagine how much time and effort it took to make such a review, so I appreciate all your efforts. At the moment I am planning to buy Simply Nourish Tuna, Pasta & Peas Casserole for my cat, but I didn’t find it in the list. Do you have any information available about the consistency and calories per serving of this product?

  • Miss KittyHappiness

    That’s great that Simply Nourish doesn’t use any by-products, I am always afraid to buy new food because I have some doubts about the ingredients. My vet prescribed vitamin D3 for my cat, so I was happy I came across this article where you describe that Simply Nourish has a rich amount of this vitamin. I guess I will buy one of the wet products for a start, my cat loves turkey flavor so I’ll buy it today. Do you know any more products with a high percentage of vitamin D3?

  • Anderson5

    Thanks for such a detailed guide, Simply Nourish has been one of my favorite brands for many years. I have 3 cats and all of them are big fans of the brand; it’s good that each of them has different favorite flavors, so they don’t fight for the same product, haha.) However, my friend told me she bought some dry products of the brand, and she says that cat poop smells bad after eating simply nourish. It would be great if you commented on the problem because I constantly tell her that my cat’s are all right with it. Still, is there any food for smelly poop?

  • Ricky Brown

    Thanks for the amazing work you did, it’s really great to read all these reviews before you actually get a cat. I’ll definitely try Simply Nourish, but I would love to read some more reviews on this site. Are there any product lines you can suggest for a 6-month old kitten?

  • Donna Brown

    Thanks for the review it’s been a pleasure to read it; I think that Simply Nourish is one of the best PetSmart brands. It’s kind of their star brand, so I hope they will try to develop this product line and produce more flavors and types of food. However, I came across many articles with the headings like “Simply Nourish vs Blue Buffalo” which means they are pretty the same. Well, at least they have not so many controversial ingredients, prove me if I’m wrong…

  • Gary O'Sullivan

    That’s pretty cool you described all the pros and cons of the Simply Nourish product line; it makes the process of choosing the right type of food much easier. My cat is 5 years old and she has always been picky; for instance, if she smells any kind of salmon in her food she won’t eat it. So that’s why it is crucially important for me not only to know all the ingredients but also the taste intensity. However, SIMPLY NOURISH Cat Mousse Treat Tuna and Salmon is the only salmon containing product she eats. Is it because the percentage of salmon in this food is much lower?

  • CatLife

    Thanks for such a detailed review, it’s been great to know that I buy the best product for my BonBon (that’s my cat’s name). However, you mentioned that there is no Simply Nourish for senior cats; the manufacturers just divide foods into ‘adult’ and ‘kitten’ series. Does it mean that all adult food is good for senior cats?

  • Theo Shelter

    I always read your food reviews, it’s great that you give a complete picture of the product, all its advantages and disadvantages. I work at a shelter, and one of my tasks is to choose the right food for each of the cats we have here; it’s quite a difficult task. You have to take into account a lot of things like temper, age, possible digestion problems and many more. Can you name some products developed especially for cats with a behavioural disorder?

  • Kitten457

    Thanks for the review, you’re my favorite blogger here, you always deliver the most detailed and useful information. I must confess that my cat Jojo is very picky; I mean, he likes only particular flavors and if I give him some products with a chicken taste he refuses to eat it. It’s been a problem for many years, at first I tried to give him such food in small portions, but it never helped. His favorite flavor is a duck, so I tried to find some products with such taste on the internet; however, I didn’t find as much food as I expected. I hope that there are Simply Nourish products with duck; however, I didn’t find them in your article…

  • Rosie Smart

    I must confess that my cat is a fan of Blue Buffalo, she eats all the products of this line, but my vet told me that we should change the brand. She says it will be good for my cat’s health; it’s not okay when a pet constantly eats the same food no matter how good it is. Which dry cat food produced by Simply Nourish would you suggest for a start?

  • Freddie Larson

    Thanks for the review, it turned out to be quite interesting and exciting, my cat has a limited ingredient diet that’s why I was happy to know that Simply Nourish has a limited ingredient lineup. My cat has a very sensitive stomach so it’s always been quite hard to find her proper nutrition. I also like the fact that Simply Nourish always places the full list of ingredients on their etiquettes. However, it is sometimes hard to find the limited lineup in the supermarket near my house so I order it online.

  • Dina777

    I am also a blogger and sometimes I make reviews about some cat products, toys and many more. However, I never posted such an exhaustive study, so I must fully express my admiration, thanks for such an informative guide. I would also like to add that my cat likes to eat grain-free food more than Whole Health Simply Nourish lineup. I consulted my vet and she said that it is okay because cats feel what vitamins and minerals they need; so she suggested just observing her behaviour and change the brands from time to time. Do you have any articles explaining such behaviour of our fluffies?

  • Rita Wilson

    Great review, I think my cat will love the SIMPLY NOURISH Cat Mousse Treat, Tuna and Salmon food. I guess it’s some kind of jerky bites other brands produce, and my Johnson loves this product. Of course, I am aware of the fact that such food cannot replace proper nutrition, it is some kind of cat chips… well, healthy ones, I guess. I also love the fact that this product is easily digestible, so I’ll use this one as a cherry on the cake for my cat.

  • Wilson991

    Well, PetSmart seems like a very respected brand, the quality of the products is high, so I used to buy Simply Nourish, however, now my cat needs a special diet. The vet told me that we must avoid salt in the food he eats, so it’s quite a problem to choose the product which is right for my fluffy. You mentioned the fact that there are no salt-free products in this line, so it’s a pity for me and for my man Bobby. Are you going to make a review of the salt-free products? I would really love to get some information on the topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *